top of page

The Myth of Sportscard Grading

Posted 1/1/26

​

One myth I've heard a lot over the years is: "Grading every card will automatically make it worth way more money."

​

As someone who's been in the hobby in some way, shape or form for 50 years or more, I've seen plenty of cards go to PSA, BGS, and SGC, with the sender hoping for that big value bump—only to learn it's not always the case.

​

Grading can increase a card's appeal (it authenticates it, protects it in a slab, and gives buyers peace of mind), especially for high-end rookies or vintage pieces in great condition. A Gem Mint 10 on the right card? Game-changer.

​

But for many cards—especially modern commons, mid-tier stuff, or ones that might only hit an 8 or 9—the grading fees, shipping, and wait time often eat up any extra value (or even leave you in the red). I've seen raw cards worth $25 that, after grading, sold for barely more than the cost to slab them.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

 

 

 

 

To many, the real joy in the hobby comes from building sets, chasing players that mean something to you, and flipping through your collection on a rainy day—not stressing over every dollar.

​

Grade the ones that excite you or feel like strong candidates, but don't feel like you have to grade everything to "win. "Collect what makes you happy—that's the part that never loses value."

​

One of the best parts of hanging with The Swami on Whatnot is we're there for fun as much as we are for profit. We look forward to seeing you Tuesday through Thursday nights at 8:30pm EST for our Whatnot show!

bottom of page